Taxi Driver Online
http://www.taxi-driver.co.uk/phpBB2/

No harm to competition by restricting station rank access
http://www.taxi-driver.co.uk/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=43080
Page 1 of 1

Author:  StuartW [ Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:31 pm ]
Post subject:  No harm to competition by restricting station rank access

Came across this fairly brief statement, or press release or whatever, on the ORR website. Which I thought stood for Office of Rail Regulator, or similar, but seems like it actually stands for Office of Rail and Road. But you have to look hard to find that, because it seems to be some kind of secret :-$

Another secret seems to be when this statement was actually published. Which is something that often annoys me on websites like this - was the statement published two days ago, or 20 years ago? :-o

The fact that I found it via a piece today on Taxi Point suggests it's quite recent. However, I suspect it isn't, and there's maybe one big clue in that regard.

And I certainly can't recall coming across this before, but maybe that's because it is quite old, and I've simply forgotten about it #-o

Anyway, this seems to be the extent of the 'market study', and there doesn't seem to be any related report, study, or other document.

And which is interesting enough, and the conclusions don't seem unreasonable. Except maybe to the extent there's no mention of plying for hire issues and the like. But that's probably a bit outside the domain of the market study [-(

(Edit - for anyone who thinks this looks familiar, then it probably is, because it's at least 14 years old. But to that extent it shouldn't look familiar because of its age :lol: )



Taxi access to railway stations market study

https://www.orr.gov.uk/monitoring-regul ... rket-study

We carried out a research study to find out whether the permits used by railway station operators to control taxi access to their stations were having a detrimental effect upon either passengers or competition.

We looked at both of the main types of station 'taxis'. The first of these two types are 'hackney carriages' which are available for immediate hire at a rank or through being hailed in the street, and can also be pre-booked. The second type are private hire vehicles, also sometimes known as 'minicabs', which must be pre-booked (often through driver's membership of 'circuits') and cannot use taxi ranks including those at stations, although private hire booking offices are located at railway stations in some cases.

We had previously received a series of complaints from individual drivers, taxi firms, and the GMB Professional Drivers' Branch (GMBPDB). These centred upon the price and availability of individual drivers' permits and tendering for sub-letting rights to concessions.

Our first objective was to assess how passengers were affected by taxis' access to stations. Our second objective was to assess how competition law might apply to these arrangements.

We based our study on desk research and a series of interviews with Network Rail, train operators, taxi firms, and the GMBPDB.

Our findings

We observed that station operators use a number of methods (referred to below as 'station permit fees') to charge taxi drivers for access to stations. Station operators that restrict access to taxis commonly tend to levy fixed annual permit fees. There are many examples of station operators giving access to hackney carriages, private hire circuits, or both.

We found no evidence that station permit fees have an impact on hackney carriage fares, which are usually set by regulation.

Nor did we find any evidence to suggest that station permit fees influence private hire fares, or reasons to believe(1) that this would be the case.

We were not made aware of any instances whereby access arrangements had a material negative impact on passenger service, for example waiting times.

It was previously suggested to us that some station permit fees might represent an instance of illegal excessive pricing under Chapter II of the UK's Competition Act (the Act). But we found no reasons to suggest that we should launch an investigation under the Act. None of the station access regimes that we observed appeared to act against passengers' interests. Because of this we decided not to commit resources to opening up an investigation.

Recommendations

We do not presently plan to explore this issue further.

Taxi drivers or circuits considering submitting a complaint to us about railway station access should clearly explain how they think station access arrangements are having an adverse impact on passengers, either directly or by harming competition.

Notes

(1) Our research suggested that station permit fees are commonly levied on a fixed basis, in other words as a fee that drivers pay on a periodic (such as annual) basis. Permit fees typically do not depend on the number of journeys made, or miles driven, by licence holders. Private hire circuits have an incentive to set fares at a level that maximises their profits.

To maximise their profits they have to price so as to find a middle ground between fares set so high that relatively few passengers are prepared to travel with them and fares that are set so low that individual journeys earn drivers relatively little money. This 'balancing act' isn't affected by whether station operators levy fixed permit fees or not or by the level that any charges are levied at.

Author:  StuartW [ Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:31 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: No harm to competition by restricting station rank acces

Quote:
We looked at both of the main types of station 'taxis'. The first of these two types are 'hackney carriages' which are available for immediate hire at a rank or through being hailed in the street, and can also be pre-booked. The second type are private hire vehicles, also sometimes known as 'minicabs', which must be pre-booked (often through driver's membership of 'circuits') and cannot use taxi ranks including those at stations, although private hire booking offices are located at railway stations in some cases.

That's perhaps the biggest clue that the study is actually quite old. No mention of the U-word, 'hailing', 'ride', 'app', or whatever :-o

Author:  StuartW [ Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:32 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: No harm to competition by restricting station rank acces

Anyway, today's Taxi Point piece is slightly wider in terms of the subject matter, and maybe a bit better in terms of the wider issues like congestion, although doesn't mention plying for hire per se. And the headline and conclusion seems surprisingly opinionated as compared to the usual Taxi Point style regarding a lot of this kind of stuff.

The article more generally is in the typical Taxi Point, er, house style, though :-o


A railway station taxi rank should serve passengers, not become a private club for the chosen few

https://www.taxi-point.co.uk/post/a-rai ... chosen-few

Author:  StuartW [ Sun Nov 15, 2026 1:34 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: No harm to competition by restricting station rank acces

Anyway, it seems Captain Cab did post the first statement above on here back in 2102 :-o

And which is probably why it doesn't use the U-word, ride-hailing etc :lol:

And the (now dead) link is to the rail regulator's website, which must have been what I was thinking about. Presumably the rail regulator doesn't exist now as a separate entity...

viewtopic.php?f=1&t=18995&hilit=GMBPDB+rail&start=15#p236805

Author:  StuartW [ Sun Nov 15, 2026 2:47 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: No harm to competition by restricting station rank acces

Incidentally, the Taxi Point piece arguably contains a low-level AI hallucination - the study was actually carried out by the Office of Rail Regulation a few years before it was abolished :-o

Which may seem nitpicking, but it's a bit like saying that the Competition and Markets Authority carried out an extensive study into the taxi and private hire industry in 2003. It was actually the Office of Fair Trading, which doesn't exist any more. But its functions in that regard are now carried out by the CMA.

To that extent the highlighted statement below is inaccurate. But that's probably because of the way the study is now presented online, and the use of AI writing tools etc [-(


Taxi Point wrote:
The Office of Rail and Road has examined this issue before. Its taxi access to railway stations market study investigated whether station permit arrangements harmed competition or passenger interests. The regulator considered concerns about permit prices, availability and the way concession rights were awarded. Station forecourts are seen as valuable commercial locations, and access to them can influence which taxi businesses receive work.

Author:  Sussex [ Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:25 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: No harm to competition by restricting station rank acces

Quote:
It was previously suggested to us that some station permit fees might represent an instance of illegal excessive pricing under Chapter II of the UK's Competition Act (the Act).

I remember about 15 years ago, the GMB (when they had proper leadership 8-[ ) in B&H made a formal complaint against the cost of station permits.

The Office of Rail Regulation, or something like that, undertook a study/investigation.

The outcome was, from memory, that because the cost of the permits wasn't a significant percentage of drivers' turnover, or that the number of punters wasn't a significant percentage of their total fares, the cost of £750 (I think) at the time wasn't an abuse of a dominant position.

Author:  x-ray [ Sun Nov 15, 2026 7:57 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: No harm to competition by restricting station rank acces

StuartW wrote:
Anyway, it seems Captain Cab did post the first statement above on here back in 2102 :-o

Back to the future Stuart ?? :D

Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC - 1 hour [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/