Taxi Driver Online

Driver thought car would ‘blow up’ after Perth taxi crash

Allan Whyte was found guilty of causing injury to a driver after he crashed his taxi into her car, propelling it into a garden fence.

A woman told a court how she feared her car would “blow up” after it was struck by a taxi driver at a Perth roundabout.

Cleaner Henrycka Bartecka was driving to work when her Vauxhall Astra was hit with such force it was propelled into a garden fence.

The 52-year-old said she had no time to act when she saw the “terrifying” headlamps of Allan Whyte’s oncoming cab.

Whyte, a local taxi driver of about 25 years, went on trial accused of causing injury to Ms Bartecka by careless driving on January 20 this year.

The 67-year-old denied the charge, claiming he did not see Ms Bartecka’s car because it did not have its lights on.

But he was found guilty after a sheriff ruled regardless if that was the case, the area was illuminated enough Whyte should have seen her.

Car was propelled into a fence

Ms Bartecka told the trial at Perth Sheriff Court she left home shortly before 6am to start her shift.

Her route took her down Campsie Road to a mini-roundabout junction with Tweedsmuir Road.

“I looked left and I could see lights of a car approaching but quite far away,” she said.

“I moved onto the roundabout and noticed the lights were approaching fast.

“When I glanced to the left again, that’s when I was hit.”

Ms Bartecka, who spoke through a Polish interpreter, said: “There was a huge noise and my car was pushed into the fence of someone’s garden.”

She said she remained conscious but after leaving the car felt dizzy and returned to the driver’s seat.
She said Whyte got out of his Toyota Corolla to check she was okay and emergency services were called.

“In the ambulance, I was terrified,” she said.

“I couldn’t breathe. I couldn’t even be breathalysed.”

She went to hospital the next day with pain in her ribs and lower back.

Ms Bartecka said she did not have time to react when she saw Whyte’s taxi.

“I remember I was holding the steering wheel tightly.”

She added: “I was very concerned the car would blow up because of the sound and the smell.”

Ms Bartecka insisted she had her lights on and said they came on automatically.

‘Not responsible’ for crash

Taking the witness stand at his trial, Whyte said he was on his way to his final job after two back-to-back five-hour shifts.

He said he only saw Ms Bartecka’s grey car seconds before he hit it.

“It had no lights on. It was a dark, grey morning and she had a dark grey car.”

“The lights were terrifying.

After slamming on the brakes, Whyte said he had to fight his way through air bags to get out.

He said Ms Bartecka shrugged when he told her: “You never had your lights on.”

Whyte, of Gray Place, Perth, said he did not feel responsible for the collision.

Failed to give way

Sheriff William Wood said: “This is the sort of collision that happens all too frequently at roundabouts up and down the country.

“They don’t usually result in injuries however, and that is maybe why this particular incident has resulted in criminal proceedings.”

He said he rejected Whyte’s claim the area was not well lit.

“Approaching the junction he would have been able to see any car coming.

“I am satisfied that Mr Whyte’s obligations and duties were to ensure it was safe to proceed before doing so and giving way to traffic from the right.

“As a result the driving fell below the standard of a careful and considerate driver.”

Whyte was found guilty of driving without care and attention by failing to give way at the roundabout, before colliding with Ms Bartecka’s vehicle and causing her injury.

The sheriff imposed five penalty points and a £400 fine.

Depends on the circumstances, and while it's normally not difficult to see unilluminated cars in streetlit areas, on occasions it's not, and generally speaking it often takes a wee bit longer to spot such cars, especially from a distance, and particularly in marginal situations. Cyclists even worse, obviously, because of the amount without lights, also their smaller visual 'footprint', and because they think they're exempt from any rules, and can thus appear at speed from absolutely anywhere

Generally easy enough to see unlit cyclists with streelights, but have had numerous close shaves over the years when they appear from nowhere behind parked cars etc. If they have proper lights generally easier to catch a quick glimpse them if there are obstacles obscuring them most of the time

Not sure precisely where the photo is from or who took it, but gives distinct impression they doorstepped him

Over careless driving?

Anyway, the roundabout certainly looks fairly straightforward with regard to seeing unilluminated cars, but who knows?

Well that's odd - noticed that the Courier's filename for the photo of the driver says something about Perth and flooding, which via Google suggests that the photo above was taken as part of a piece about flooding in Perth last year (although that particular photo doesn't appear in the article here):

https://www.thecourier.co.uk/fp/news/pe ... ng-latest/

So looks like they didn't actually doorstep him with regarding the driving incident, and the photo was taken with regard to another matter.

Funny thing, though, is that the article about the driving offence says he's been a taxi driver for 25 years, but the article about the flooding says he'd just retired from the Forestry Commission

I suppose he could have been a part-time driver continuing in the trade after retiral from his 'proper' job, but who knows?

(The flooding article is about Gray Street, while the driving piece says he's from Gray Place in Perth, which doesn't seem to exist, so presumably that's just an error.)