Nice to see you debating some policy sunset. The things you point to are SNP policies now, not pros or cons of independence. There's nothing there that a future Scottish government couldn't change.
I'll have a go at your points but remember, I'm a socialist and I'm not a member of the SNP.
sunset wrote:
You make look at the council tax freeze ( this actually damaging public services)
Here I partially agree with you. It's not good for local government finances to continue freezing this. Need should be addressed by council tax benefit, not by squeezing council services to the bone.
Unfortunately, UK government policy is to squeeze services to the bone and to cut council tax benefit.
sunset wrote:
Free prescriptions ( again this is damaging the NHS)
That is just plain wrong.
Official figures tell us any savings from means testing would be swallowed up by the bureaucracy required to do it. So instead of spending money on medicines, you spend it on a system of checking everyone's means.
This isn't about rich people getting free aspirin, since the majority of the NHS drug budget goes on disabilities and conditions which would be exempt anyway, and people who would qualify after means testing.
sunset wrote:
Tuition fees (again no need to let the super rich off here but again he did)
Education should be free. If you means test the kids, you will find they almost all qualify, since they've just left school and have little or no means of their own. Their parents should be contributing towards their education, but there's a better way to do that. I'll come to that later.
I'm surprised you didn't mention SLABs desire to means test free bus passes?
Perhaps you realise that these are used disproportionally by the poor and needy.
The super rich may have free bus passes but they don't often travel with the great unwashed.
sunset wrote:
super rich earners on higher incomes should be paying for these services
You are right and they should be doing it through the tax system.
The 5% tax cut for the wealthiest in society handed out by Westminster was an insult to the vast majority of tax payers and should be reversed immediately.
Income tax avoidance costs the UK 15 times as much as benefit fraud, yet NONE of the UK parties wants to tackle this. Now why is that?
Trident replacement is a £100 billion waste of money which most Scots don't want. Isn't it strange that SLAB can't find the moral courage to oppose this ridiculous waste of public money?